Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Girls' BFF

 
Next Answer »
userpic
userpic

Are children better off in loveless marriages or broken homes? I know economically better in marriage but emotional toll?Husband doesn't love me,willing to keep me for cook/clean/childcare if I "leave him alone to do as he wants." He's rich & protected by prenup, I'm poor, age 43 w/1 year old baby + expecting baby #2.

Not for nothing, but I get the impression that for the logistics here, you need to consult a lawyer as opposed to Guyspeak.

But I can speak to the larger idea of: loveless marriage or broken home. I am a product of a "broken home" to so speak. And my life was great. I have two mothers that love me and care for me and had a great family life and upbringing. I maintained a very strong and close relationship with all of my parents. I also have a daughter. Her mother and I are no longer together, but we co-parent and are extremely civil and respectful of one another. We are able to talk, laugh, and work together for our daughter's best interest.

A loveless marriage though, that's something that children feel and see. They learn how to love from parents and while you may not see love via husband and wife in a broken home, you do get a lot of love from your parents and hopefully you see happy. Loveless marriages tend to evoke and illustrate non-love. You actively see people who don't love each other and go out of their way to show it at times. I'm not saying its not possible to ensure that your kids dont see it, but it has to be hell on you as a person. And if you aren't happy, that will translate down to your children. At least in my non-expert opinion.

So I'd guess that a "broken home" that's happy is a better situation than a loveless marriage that can feel like a prison.

Talk 8
Love it? Hate it? 6
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

8 Comments

user-pic

You also have to think about what message you're sending your kids. You want them to know that it's better to be happy than not. As well, you deserve to be happy. Do you really want to be in that relationship? I doubt it. No one wants to 'pretend' to be happy when they could meet someone who could make them happy. I agree with Panama that two separate people who are happy and pursuing their happiness is a much better environment for children than two people living together who are unhappy.

Regardless of what you present to the kids, they'll sense it. Besides, today there is no normal family so the affects or stigma that you felt when you were younger most likely doesn't apply today.

silkysly

Child support is never protected by a prenup....

user-pic

Just saying, my mother divorced my father when I was 5, and I'm glad she did. I have come to know my father in my 20's (he was never there for me as I was growing up), and I could see how potentially horrible childhood I could have had if they stayed together. My mother is an amazing role model for me; she is strong, brave, independent and passionate about her work. She taught me that happiness isn't about finding a man, it's about finding what I want to do and pursuing it.

user-pic

Mamasgirl,
Thank you for your comment. I am glad you are such a wellrounded young lady no matter what you've been through in childhood. I meant to vote "positive heart" on your comment but accidentally pushed "broken heart". I'm sorry about that. I don't know how to reverse it. Again, thank you for a great comment.

user-pic

Mamasgirl,
Thank you for your comment. I am glad you are such a wellrounded young lady no matter what you've been through in childhood. I meant to vote "positive heart" on your comment but accidentally pushed "broken heart". I'm sorry about that. I don't know how to reverse it. Again, thank you for a great comment.

user-pic

Children know when things are going bad in a marriage. The job of parents is too lead by example. When you or your spouse are cheating on one another what message are you sending to your kids? I know a couple he constantly cheats on his wife. He leaves her with the kids sometimes for months. Then they reconcile he comes back and if they get into a fight again he leaves. This has been going on for years. What a horrible message they are sending to their kids. They have a boy and a girl, the message they are giving them is it's okay for guys to cheat. The mother for allowing this to keep happening she is telling the girl this is acceptable. I see this marriage as abusive to these children. I hope these children will grow up and remember their parents awful marriage and not chose a marriage like that.
I am divorced from my husband. We are friends my kids sometimes hate it because we are tougher parents than when we were married. I know it's hard but you need to forgive one another in a divorce. Lead by example and show them you can end the bitterness and move on. I did I have people who are envious of me because I get along with my ex. We hang out together and my ex-in-laws invite me to parties because I have a great attitude.

user-pic

Do what you can to save the marriage. That's just my opinion. You two did exchange vows after all. Fight for it. Wait until baby number two is born at least. As a divorced single mother you will still have to cook, clean and look after the kids. So leaving you husband because you don't like doing those things doesn't make sense. Just think very carefully before walking away. Time to be practical. If you decide to walk, keep it quiet until you have everything organized. It may take a year of planning.

user-pic

I hope you leave him. I'm 21 and have grown up seeing my parents (and other couples) in a poisonous relationship; I wish they had divorced years ago. Now, I don't believe in marriage or relationships and am engaged to someone but cannot bear the idea of going through with it anymore because I am so terrified I will end up in the same situation my parents are in... on top of that I have man issues and expect all men to be like my dad (even though they are not). I can't see myself ever having a healthy marriage because I grew up with my parents...

I believe that people should try what they can to make their marriages work but when all fails (especially when the other party doesn't care), divorce is ideal, regardless or whether or not children are involved... staying married "for the sake of the kids" doesn't make sense to me... I know divorce would have been hard on me, but at least I wouldn't have to live with seeing how much my parents can't stand each other..

I think you should be true to yourself in this situation. I strongly believe that people must first care for themselves if they are to care for others

I really agree with panama jackson..

I wish you the best of luck

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive:

Trending Topics

  1. 123 entries are tagged with
  2. 82 entries are tagged with
  3. 109 entries are tagged with
  4. 78 entries are tagged with
  5. 109 entries are tagged with
  6. 313 entries are tagged with
  7. 117 entries are tagged with
  8. 1129 entries are tagged with
  9. 83 entries are tagged with
  10. 93 entries are tagged with
  11. 79 entries are tagged with
  12. 120 entries are tagged with
  13. 124 entries are tagged with
  14. 91 entries are tagged with
  15. 96 entries are tagged with
  16. 93 entries are tagged with
  17. 198 entries are tagged with
  18. 237 entries are tagged with
  19. 79 entries are tagged with
  20. 79 entries are tagged with
  21. 84 entries are tagged with
  22. 273 entries are tagged with
  23. 763 entries are tagged with
  24. 95 entries are tagged with
  25. 87 entries are tagged with