Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Mystery Man

 
Next Answer »
userpic
userpic

have you ever used a girl as your psychiatrist? as in, you weren't really in love with her but she was always there to listen about your issues?

Sometimes, as a bit of fun, I like to throw a bonus question open to the readers to answer. It is time for another "Readers Respond," with a perfect question for it.

I will answer this question in the comments in two days time - meanwhile, have fun!

Usual rules apply, lets stay reasonably polite and respectful of each other and the OP, eh?

Talk 20
Love it? Hate it? 1
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

20 Comments

user-pic

I never used someone in that way.

silkysly

Wasn’t that on Sex in the City? Anyway…, low people do low things. Nuff said.

user-pic

Don't we all sound off on our friends? As they do us. In regards to a guy using me as his psychiatrist - I have found that anyone that I may have been in love with never divulged as much as I would have liked them to. And as a result I think I read body language cues well... Actually come to think of it most guys that I know really do not talk a lot. The ones that do go on and on are not really saying anything anyway... (Is this a trick question?)

silkysly

He doesn’t want to “share” he wants to unload on her. When he's done, he will probably move on.

user-pic

It would depend on the girl. If you guys are long-time friends, then it's like SWSNBN said- no big deal because everyone sounds off on friends.

However, you specifically said "used" which leads me to believe that you know that this girl is into you and possibly wants more of a relationship with you. In that case, the onus is on you to be honourable and to NOT give her any reason to think that you might be interested in her. To continue to "use" her in that case would be utterly selfish on your part.

Note: SWEEPING GENERALIZATION AHEAD. Girls talk about their feelings and emotions. It's what we do. We play psychiatrist to each other all the time. It's a way to strengthen our relationships with each other as well as vent. If you're specifically singling this girl out for therapy sessions, she might be reading into it, especially if she's already interested in you.

Bottom line: tread carefully. You run the risk of using her emotionally, which is no bueno.

user-pic

from a woman's perspective, i had a guy pretend to be in love with me because he was using me as an emotional crutch. that kind of behavior is deceitful and manipulative if you're dating/have shown romantic interest but have not made it official. when she realizes that you're "using" her, don't turn things around on her and say that she was "naive" because she obviously cares for and trusts you to be honest. anyone that admits to "using" a woman in any way, with or without what he deems as "consent," is a scumbag, plain and simple. if you need a psychiatrist, get a job with health insurance.

silkysly

He needs therapy. Wait…, he’s getting that for free. ;-/

user-pic

Well, how old are you? If you are in your late 20s or 30s or later then I would say it is wrong to pull someone along just because you like them as a sounding board. If you are young and neither are really looking for a wife/husband but just some fun then I don't see much wrong with that. She could very well be getting what she wants from the relationship.

But, as I said, if she is looking for love or a future then you are leading her on for your own gains, which is not good. It is also not age dependent, I used the above situations as reference but there are young people who look for love and a future. You need to know where she stands.

user-pic

I have a guy friend that I dated when I was in my teens (he's 4 years older than me) and we are both in our 40's now and he is definitely my psychiatrist. I even call him "the doctor". He is always there to give me a man's perspective and listen to whatever is going on and almost always gives me sound, intuitive advice. I don't know that I would consider it using him because I care about him deeply and I consider him one of my best friends!

user-pic

Doesnt that explain a friendship?

If your letting her think that you are in love with her and you guys really are in a relationship then ya this is messed up. Dont lead girls on that way. But if you like having her there to talk to and vent to and just be there but you arent in love with her well to me that explains what a friendship is.

user-pic

Doesnt that explain a friendship?

If your letting her think that you are in love with her and you guys really are in a relationship then ya this is messed up. Dont lead girls on that way. But if you like having her there to talk to and vent to and just be there but you arent in love with her well to me that explains what a friendship is.

user-pic

Interesting. So if a guy were to use me as his psychiatrist, that would lead me to believe that our "relationship" was going smoothly because opening up on thoughts and feelings and secrets is how I as a female would normally bond. It is how we as women relate... Not a good thing to identify for guys in general to know and use.

rab09011

But what if he wasn't interested in being in a relationship with you?
Why would the OP phrase it in terms of "using" somebody?
Doesn't that mean you don't reciprocate any of things being done/offered to/for you?

user-pic

Only the OP can tell us what he meant by "use"... If he is just talking at me
without any sincere interest in anything going on in my life - am pretty sure I would notice - as would any woman. If he is not obvious and leads me to think he cares, that's just the worst because likely I would reciprocate with genuineness and he would be making me a fool for caring.

user-pic

Think I've been a psychiatrist to someone before, who was going through a hard time. It was very confusing for me, because I felt if he's sharing this stuff with me, he must really trust me and therefore, like me. I was wrong, he ended up comitting to someone else. But it made me question...does he share this same stuff with her? If a guy is starting a relationship does he share the heavy stuff with a girl he's still trying to impress, or does he save that stuff for the girl he's not interested in, unafraid of what she thinks because he's not interested? What's funny is that's the girl he should be with because he can be himself with her completely, no holding back. The same can be said for us girls too. Not sure if it's true, but just something I've thought about since then.

user-pic

I'd love to hear a guy's answer...

user-pic

I've been a psychiatrist for some of my male-friends and they, especially one of them, have been for me. When is just friendship and you have the confidence with them to talk about your inner thoughts and fears, that's something good. The problem, I think, comes when what you (or she) wants is not friendship and therapy is just a convinient way to be together. Then your losing your time and hers. I've learned that when there's attraction between a man and a woman friendship is not possible, 'cause there are other interests. But if there's no attraction from both, then be friends, have friend-therapy together, talk about things. And stop worrying.

Mystery Man

OK, time is up.

It is the behavior of a complete dick.

You, constantly bugging her with your problems and concerns, are c*ckblocking her, which, as every guy knows, is simply not acceptable.

Back off, deal with your own problems, and let her have a life and a relationship. Not just a toxic friendship.

silkysly

yep...

Rae

Thanks for finally piping in MM! I was getting tired of every person saying the exact same thing while beating around the bush.

Any guy who does that is a TOTAL JERK-OFF!

And... when a girl (who is having this done to her) finally says something to the effect of a "date" or liking him, he retreats and freaks out.

Guys... Don't do this... It is just an invitation to a swift kick in the head (I'll let you choose which one).

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive:

Trending Topics

  1. 95 entries are tagged with
  2. 59 entries are tagged with
  3. 70 entries are tagged with
  4. 61 entries are tagged with
  5. 57 entries are tagged with
  6. 214 entries are tagged with
  7. 91 entries are tagged with
  8. 864 entries are tagged with
  9. 60 entries are tagged with
  10. 64 entries are tagged with
  11. 57 entries are tagged with
  12. 93 entries are tagged with
  13. 89 entries are tagged with
  14. 61 entries are tagged with
  15. 53 entries are tagged with
  16. 150 entries are tagged with
  17. 183 entries are tagged with
  18. 63 entries are tagged with
  19. 55 entries are tagged with
  20. 79 entries are tagged with
  21. 60 entries are tagged with
  22. 237 entries are tagged with
  23. 499 entries are tagged with
  24. 95 entries are tagged with
  25. 58 entries are tagged with