Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Wise-Ass

 
Next Answer »
userpic
userpic

My ex and I had a tumultuous relationship for 2 years, during which he broke up with me 10+ times. Now he wants me back, says he is seeking therapy to become a better person and wants to marry me and have kids. I love him dearly. Should I believe him?

Should you believe what, that he wants to change? Sure. Nobody wants to be a dick, they just are. They can't control themselves. Then later when they've cooled off, they feel badly about their behavior and resolve to you and to themselves not to do it again.

Should you believe he will change? Sorry, but I wouldn't hold my breath. Change is hard, especially big change. If he had broken up with you once or twice over two years, that'd be one thing, but more than ten times? Nuh uh. That's psycho territory right there.

Hey look, I'm all for second chances. Everyone screws up sometimes. I believe in forgiveness and allowing people to redeem themselves for past bad behavior. But that doesn't mean I necessarily trust them not to act that way again. You can tame a tiger, but I wouldn't turn my back on it. It's still a tiger.

Something tells me this is not the first time your guy has made a promise to get help and become a nicer person. And therein lies the problem. If he really wanted to change, he would've by now. If there's help to be had, why isn't he already getting it?

I'm not saying he's a liar; he probably does love you and wants to treat you better. But there's a big difference between wanting and doing, and it's the doing that matters, of course. If your ass is on fire, you don't just want it to stop burning; you're doing anything and everything you can to put out the fire -- running, screaming, dropping, rolling and/or jumping into a swimming pool. It's a question of motivation.

It's not that the guy can't change. He can, but not without a lot of hard work and some difficult self-inventory, which takes time, courage and unfaltering motivation. That's why you shouldn't even think about dating him again until he gets some help. Notice I didn't say "promises to get some help." I said "gets some help." As in, now. As in, before you so much as let him buy you a smoothie.

I'll say what I always say: talk is cheap. If he really loves you and wants to be with you, he'll do the work first. If you go ahead and take him back now, he has no incentive to do better -- "She took me back so I must be okay" -- and never will.

Forget marriage and kids. Don't even talk about that stuff. That's years away, if ever. You don't even know if you can go out to dinner and get along. One step at a time. And step one is him getting off his butt and putting his money where his mouth is. Love is action, not words.

Good luck. You'll need it. I hope you two can work things out.

Talk 9
Love it? Hate it? 6
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

9 Comments

Harmony

YES! It's not the believing he wants to change that is holding things up, it's the needing to know that he HAS changed. Hold out for what you deserve, do not let love be blinding...or you WILL regret it.

user-pic

Please resist the urge to procreate with this moron.

Daisy

Wow. I don't believe I'd give anyone the opportunity to break up with me 10+ times. Who needs that kind of stress and craziness and drama? In order for him to have broken up with you 10+ times, you would have had to agree to take him back that many. After two or three break-ups at most with someone, I think I would have washed my hands of him altogether. I just wouldn't see any point in continuing to try to make something work that obviously isn't working. Perhaps you have a lot more patience than I do. Seriously, I'd have to wonder what you see in him to have taken him back so many times. My advice would be to end it once and for all and move forward. Don't look back. You deserve better treatment than that. Everyone does. I think maybe your self-esteem is low and needs a bit of a boost. You need to realize and value your own self worth and take care of your own interests for a change in my humble opinion.

user-pic

Only give him another chance if you want more of the same, talk and no action, again and again and again. And if you do want more, then you need to look into therapy for yourself.

Sorry, life's to short to spend on this kind of craziness.

user-pic

i agree with the advice. my ex broke up with me a few times. Last month he told me he was GOING to see a therapist, GOING to stop smoking weed, WANTED to marry me, WANTED to treat me better, blahblahblah. I gave him another chance and lo and behold...he turned back into an asshole.

Assholes do a lot of talking...but that's just it. TALK.

user-pic

Kick this prick to the curb. Sheesh - enough is enough!

user-pic

I'm reading my own freakin story! I had the same problem. My guy was a beer swilling bi-polar freak. He was so funny and fun to be around in the beginning. What a great guy! The sex was awesome as well. However, do you want to keep hearing the same story over and over? Chances are, he will never change.

Luckily, I realized that I deserve better than empty promises and heartbreak every other day. If the situation is anything like mine, he will text you sweet and funny messages to get you to melt (or shoot you a sh**y one). Once he gets you to respond, he either makes every promise under the sun or blasts back evil and nasty messages to hurt you. Am I right? (Do NOT respond! Clear you head!)

Like the previous commenter stated: You should have more respect for yourself. I know that it sucks being single - not having that person to snuggle up next to every night. (I got a dog to remedy that.) Trust me... Mr. Right will come along when you least suspect it. My last guy (The a**hole in question) totally jaded me and frankly turned me into a girl who is just tired of taking BS from any guy. In other words, "I was numb."

It actually made me stronger and made me able to voice what is actually on my mind when I finally did decide to move forward with my life. Four months later, I met Mr. Right. I think that what has made our relationship bloom is the fact that I made him aware that: 1) I HAVE RESPECT FOR MYSELF. 2) I DO NOT NEED A MAN IN MY LIFE. 3) I LOVE ME - REGARDLESS OF MY FAULTS. 4) I WILL NOT PUT UP WITH EMPTY PROMISES OR LET DOWNS ANY MORE.

In a nutshell, If you want to be with me, this is how I am. Take it or leave it.

I think you need time to get to know and love yourself before you can realize what you are really looking for in your soul mate. This guy is NOT your soul mate. Love is patient. Love is kind. Love is not supposed to hurt.

Take my advice and take care of YOU first. Once you realize the beautiful person that you are, true love will find you. I promise. (It's definately NOT with this guy. Be strong, sister!)

user-pic

i agree but it is hard

user-pic

Siiiiigh.

If only my love, the love of my life, with whom I had 5 years of friendship including 2 years of engagement, would wake up and smell the garbage that started off as a rebound and is currently a more serious "relationship" of convenience and co-dependence with a clingy, needy, selfish, emotionally and mentally manipulative, indecent (posted a dirty song about how far physically the he and she had gone in their relationship on his Facebook Wall for everyone--including his mother and me--to see), and mean (posted "loving" AND "I miss you" messages where I could see them instead of reserving them for chat or calling him on the phone). He was going to go to China for a year to earn money and she wailed about it and kept on wailing so that as far as I know, that plan is no-go. We were apart for most of the first year of our engagement and he checked-in with me to ensure that I was fine with him taking on a teaching job for a semester and when the job was renewed, he checked-in with me again. The next year, I had jobs: teaching and residential care of senior citizens and checked-in with him. We communicated several times daily/nightly to talk about our days/nights and made decisions on job goals/objectives, having kids, having sex, respecting our religious differences. He wanted me to live with him and asked me twice. I said no both times because I was in the middle of a semester and I couldn't leave my hometown, family and friends, and I didn't know if I'd have a job the next semester. When our break happened, he gave me the reasons that he felt he weren't moving towards further intimacy (we didn't have sex because I wasn't ready nor did he help me be ready any of the times that were possible), moving towards marriage (the cohabitation although he didn't bring up that he'd found us a place; we came to compromises on venues although he said we didn't) or communication (because most of our communication was after midnight when both of us were too tired or too lonely to be much else than randy), or geographically (I couldn't move out easily and every time he applied and/or interviewed for a job out of state, the job went to someone else or the offer was waffled on or removed; I still agreed every time to move out with him wherever he landed a job and inquired or was told about the opportunity for spousal hire. He added to his reasons by saying we didn't connect emotionally. This was one of the harder blows. Not as hard as him saying that we, as he saw it, had different expectations and goals without telling me or answering what those were when I asked. He told me that his future plans were synching easily with hers. Again: no telling and no answering. I bargained and pleaded; I started to cry on the phone and he told me to accept what had happened, initially cavalierly and then agitatedly. He didn't call me back. He has been on/off in his behavior: texting me to see if I'm around to chat; told me repeatedly he found me attractive and missed certain parts of my body and wanted photos of them until I called him on it: "Why did you.." and he responded: "I didn't...it's a dead loss for us."

She broke up with him and unfriended him several times one night and has repeatedly hurt and/or left him. He's taken her back every time but when I told him I was diagnosed with severe depression from missing him during our long-distance relationship yet he knew that I had a job as well as family and friends and his love, I managed to find the silver lining in every day, he broke his promises to marry me and stay by my side. I never trusted her because she came up in conversation as one of his close friends and since I'd only known me to be his closest friend, I was immediately suspicious and warned him because she was newly single and already in a casual relationship. This woman is a undergrad and young mother, a relationship-ruiner who flirted openly with him in-person and on Facebook via 3 love songs--which he liked, to my dismay. When I told him to tell her that she was being disrespectful to me, him, us and our relationship, she responded that she was being funny, mischevious, and meant no harm because she was re-evaluating (what, I never knew). She unfriended him repeatedly and he re-added her every time. My high school counselor friend has initially diagnosed her with Borderline Personality Disorder and from researching it, I've come to the conclusion that she has had the symptoms.

I'm at a loss as to what to do. It's like he changed into a man that I don't recognize most days although I know him so well in some ways as he knows me so well in some ways. He continues to post euphoric love songs, including 3 that were his songs for me, because I know how excited he can be about romance and sex. I don't post any love songs because I feel old, as if I'm stuck in this alternate universe that's like a hell. We were the first grad school program couple and were looked upon with initial disbelief and ultimate support. His family, friends, relatives, and former boarding school attendees all were curious and eager to meet me. His family loved me. I could feel their love. I feel, too, saddened because he told me he'll always love me yet has been alternately cooler and warmer. I dream of us together, more happy, peaceful, content, excited, and joyful. We didn't accept each other as we are and not encourage, support, and spur each other to be better people. I sense that neither one in this situation does this. He's taking care of her, her kid, his workaholic mother, his split-shift working brother's kids (while his girlfriend sits at home, going on Facebook Mobile and whining about how bored she is, and taking partial care of their baby daughter) and is writing film, etc. reviews for little money. He continues to be tired or exhausted or sleepy. I worry about him and his heart and multiple health conditions. I pray, beg, and wish that he'll wake up to smell the rose of my love.

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive:

Trending Topics

  1. 96 entries are tagged with
  2. 59 entries are tagged with
  3. 70 entries are tagged with
  4. 61 entries are tagged with
  5. 58 entries are tagged with
  6. 215 entries are tagged with
  7. 91 entries are tagged with
  8. 865 entries are tagged with
  9. 60 entries are tagged with
  10. 64 entries are tagged with
  11. 57 entries are tagged with
  12. 93 entries are tagged with
  13. 89 entries are tagged with
  14. 61 entries are tagged with
  15. 53 entries are tagged with
  16. 151 entries are tagged with
  17. 183 entries are tagged with
  18. 63 entries are tagged with
  19. 55 entries are tagged with
  20. 79 entries are tagged with
  21. 60 entries are tagged with
  22. 239 entries are tagged with
  23. 501 entries are tagged with
  24. 95 entries are tagged with
  25. 58 entries are tagged with