Who says TV doesn't teach us anything? If you would have asked me this question 3 months ago I would have told you this means your guy is far from impressed with the sex and giving you a rather lukewarm B- in bed. But, after painfully and then enjoyably watching this entire season of The Bacehlor, I have a different answer.
The reason being: Brad Womack. Now, say what you will about his staggering physique and pleasant face, but this man is no Shakespeare. His vocabulary makes toddlers impatient, but so be it. When he uses words like "terrific" or "great" he means...a lot. His "terrific" is a wordsmith's "visceral bliss." Your guy's "you're all right with me" could be his "your every touch leaves me fully satiated."
So, I'd say, take it as a compliment and see how he expresses himself in other areas. The underlying concern here, it seems, is that you thought the sex was batsh*t awesome and he didn't fully concur to your liking. My further advice is go back to the bedroom drawing board and have great sex again. If his eyes cross, his toes curl and his orgasm lasts 28 soul buckling seconds AND he still says, "that was pretty neat" you know you got a Womackian Poet on your hands, and for many that ain't too bad.
Funny Guy
If I could love this answer a hundred more times, I would. "Womackian Poet" ~ Brilliant!
He could also be one of these guys who fancies himself a modern Humphry Bogart, kind of a "here's lookin at you kid" sort of line, I'd have to here how he said it, and know more about him to make that judgment though.
Bhahahahahahaha!
I say things like "you're alright with me" as a flirty, unserious way of complimenting a guy. Rather than telling him how much I like him and being sappy about it, it's more of a sarcastic approach that lets him know you like him. Maybe that's where he was going with it? Just a thought.
I don't know which is worse; knowing that there are guys out there with Womackian vocabulary or there are guys out there who could sit through a season of 'The Bachelor'. ;p
My boyfriend says "that was fun" after we have sex. I see/hear him when he orgasms so I know his "that was fun" is because he doesnt know what else to say.
I think he's into it, just is awkward about saying "omg that was amazing, youre amazing", ya know?
Womackian Poet, ftw.