Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Newsworthy

Next Entry »
userpic

Do Women Really Like Independent Boyfriends and Husbands?

Nearly all men say that they'd love nothing more than for a woman to approach them and say, "hey, I just want some sex. Let's get it on." And nearly all men are liars. While there are a scant few who'd probably jump at that opportunity, the majority of us would think we were being set up for a reality show, robbery, or the ultimate okey doke. Jury's out on which is worse.

It's in that same vein of "you're full of *CENSORED* ness" that I read this recent article. According to a new Wal-green's study, half of women would rather have the flu themselves than deal with a sick husband. Now, I've heard from various women that all men suck when we're suck. We become whiny, needy, petulent, self-centered, 12-year-olds who pretend that nobody's ever been sick like we've been sick before.

Basically, we become women.

*rimshot*

*ducking tomatoes*

Apparently, all men turn into p*****s when we're sick. Oh, the humanity.

While I've heard women say this before, I can't honestly say that I know any men who turn punk when they get sick. Hell, I had pneumonia for two weeks and basically took care of myself and I felt like absolute crap. But that's neither here nor there. I do believe that there are some men who act that way.

But here's my point, I almost think that women need us become weaklings. When we don't? We get complaints about being too independent and not letting our women take care of us. It's almost like a woman-mettle-proving ground or something. Every time I've been sick and told my girlfriend (at the time) or friend, they've often immediately gone into "Help P Survive Mode" and I stopped them in their tracks with the, "I'm cool. I got it. Relax."

"You don't need me to fix you any soup?"

"No. I got it."

"You don't need me to get you medicine?"

"Naw. Already did it."

"You want me to hold you like a baby and make you feel better?"

"I'm a grown ass man."

"You're too independent. What? You don't need me?"

Womp. Womp. Womp.

Nine times out of ten, it goes directly there. See, I think that most women want to be needed. In fact, I'm sure I wrote a blog about that before. And a sick man is a perfect time to prove that to be true. But if dude rebukes your help, as a woman, what are you supposed to do? Watch your loved one get better without you? Let him cook his own walking dead meals?

I'll never understand this, but I think women take independent men (inside a relationship) as personal affronts to their womanhood. If he doesn't need you, why are you there? I've had that argument (and lost that argument merely because you can't fight an emotional argument with logic) more times than I care to admit. Something about women and us "needing" you all.

So while most women probably do get annoyed with their sick husbands' needy ways, they ALSO subconsciously relish in the fact that they're taking care of their family. You take that away from most women and they look more lost than Bill O'Reilly at a Maroon 5 concert.

Not that I don't think those women were being honest when they answered. Nobody likes annoying people, but I wonder if they had been asked if they'd prefer to have a husband who never needed any help when he was sick, how those responses would turn out.

Panama says they'd no likey.

So what do you think? Would you rather have the flu yourself, ladies, than deal with a sick husband? And then, would you rather have a husband who always took care of himself when he was sick and didn't need you for anything?

Inquiring minds would like to know.

Talk 11
Love it? Hate it? 1
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

11 Comments

user-pic

I don't think its about the help he may or may not need. My guy drives me insane when he's sick! Yes id rather have a sickness for a week myself than deal with him being sick. I still have to do all my regular stuff, cleaning and taking care of kids and dogs. If he's sick he's apparently incapable of doing any of it. At least the house is still running if im sick. If it were up to him we would all stop and wait til he's better.

user-pic

I don't think its about the help he may or may not need. My guy drives me insane when he's sick! Yes id rather have a sickness for a week myself than deal with him being sick. I still have to do all my regular stuff, cleaning and taking care of kids and dogs. If he's sick he's apparently incapable of doing any of it. At least the house is still running if im sick. If it were up to him we would all stop and wait til he's better.

user-pic

Everyone, man and woman, wants to feel needed.

user-pic

I love taking care of my man when he's under the weather - putting him under my wee wing, making him feel all warm and cosy and safe. He does show his appreciation which is maybe why I don't mind doing it. I guess he's a good patient.

user-pic

I personally do not want to take care of anyone but myself. I take of my son when he's sick because he's a freaking child. If you're an adult and you are not sick enough to be in the hospital, you can take care of yourself. If you want me to do something, ask me nicely. I have empathy for those who are ill but I am no nurse.

Women are socialized to be caregivers sir. We're not born that way.

user-pic

I myself am extremely independent. I baby only as much as I'd myself want to be babied. I definitely want a man who can handle himself during a measly cold! But I'd want him to also accept SOME help, like making soup during a particularly bad flu or something. Not because I'm a woman, but out of empathy/compassion as a partner. I'd expect him to do the return too. He's gotta be independent, but I don't want to refuse EVERY bit of help I offer him...

aspiringgeekygirl

I would prefer it if my boyfriend/Partner let me take care of him but to do so that didn't undermine his independance.

chrissie1101

history changes preferences lol i would rather have the flu for a year than be around my ex and his pathetic toe thing for even a minute. my bf now is more like you BFF so i think thats hot lol

user-pic

My wife is definitely a caring type. She gets annoyed when I resist her care, as I'm stubbornly independent. But she does it well. Heck, in her home country, she used her influence to get a doctor to see me ahead of 60+ people in the waiting room.

user-pic

Panama's bitter breed of sexism is getting to be a bore...

user-pic

Exactly.

"We become whiny, needy, petulent, self-centered, 12-year-olds who pretend that nobody's ever been sick like we've been sick before.

Basically, we become women."

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive: