Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Pop Culture

Next Entry »
userpic

The Perfect Woman

We get a lot of questions here, some fun, some impossible, some outright odd and some that we can answer with our eyes and minds shut, as we've done them that often.
Then there is the whole class of opinion questions. What is hot, what is sexy, what do you like in bed, can I make you a sandwich (note, that one is totally made up, but roast beef, cheese and horseradish, if anyone is offering).

Basically, snatches of conversations with different readers that, answered or not, have added up to the idea of what makes the perfect woman. Or, rather, who would be the perfect woman.

There isn't one single perfect woman in popular culture.

A few, like Electra, Lara Croft or Miranda Priestly from The Devil Wears Prada, come close, but apparently Hollywood is not yet ready for the awesome potential of a true kick-ass female lead, and I do mean lead. Not eye candy. Not someone who gives it all up for lurve. Not 2 dimensional comic fodder. The actual lead character carrying a film on her own.
There is, however, one TV show and associated movie that contains my perfect woman. She is just in four separate pieces, which is not how I tend to normally prefer my woman, preferring the holistic and blood and fragment free approach.

I refer, of course, to Firefly/Serenity. Lets look - in order of importance. Yes, I know they are fictional. But each of these actresses goes well above and beyond the job, making the character their own.

Kaylee (Jewel Staite): Now this is, if you like, the ground state of my perfect woman. Competent, knows stuff that I don't have clue freaking one about. Not afraid to get her hands dirty fixing something. Yet with an innocence and exuberance about her, a sheer joy in life and the fun it offers that keeps every experience new and fresh and exciting. Happy, nearly always cheerful and completely unselfconscious.

Zoe (Gina Torres): Why second in importance? Watch her interact with her husband in any episode at all. She is tougher than him, faster than him, more pragmatic than him. Yet the love and affection shines through. He may be a leaf on the wind, she is his wind. That is something worth having.

River (Summer Glau): OK, what is a complete psycho who could chop me into sushi in about 4 seconds flat if she didn't like what I was thinking doing on the list at all? Satisfying my death wish? Well, no.
She needs protection. Doesn't need it physically, if the sh*t hits the fan I'll just hold her coat and try not to get splattered with blood and various other bodily fluids, but at the same time she does need it emotionally. A guy needs to be needed sometimes. And sometimes, as from the awesome line "You've always taken care of me. My turn," well a guy needs protection too. At least from time to time. No shame in admitting that.

Inara (Morena Baccarin): Actually, someone I ignored for a long time. Sure, she has mad bed and social skills - that is fairly irrelevant to any guy over the age of about 16 who has any self confidence whatsoever. Then, re-watching several times, you see her true strength. Compassion. It is not flashy, or in your face. Just there. How it should be. The bedrock of her character.

So, in summary, my ideal woman is competent, has an innocent joy in life, a rock hard core of love and respect, both needs me and is capable of flipping right the f*ck out and is compassionate. Not something you really needed to know. Something I did.
So why do I have to combine these four characters at all? They all sound appealing in their own ways.

Well, mainly because I want a human being, not an archetype, to share my life. A woman with both virtues and faults. You note that none of them have what you would call faults, except for River being completely insane. Zoe is a bit too literal, Kaylee is a little too trusting, Inara is a little too full of herself. Yet these women are supposedly some of the best characterizations of women to come out on film in the last decade. Compare them to the male characters in the series, and they come off as admittedly strong and comely two dimensional characters.
Are directors and producers terrified of women? The studio's incessant demand for "more of the same" makes it impossible to have a real woman character? Or it could be that scriptwriters, like all novelists ever (guilty), are lazy b*stards that use cliches instead of character. I don't know. All I know is I am tired of it.

Aren't you?

Nick, please stop muttering "Welcome to 2002, idiot!" It isn't my fault I had to go that far back for the appropriate analogy. Take it up with the studios.
Please!


Talk 18
Love it? Hate it? 10
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

18 Comments

user-pic

*Collective "Oooooh, now I get it!" from the audience*

user-pic

Somebody watched "Serenity" last weekend and spent a great deal of time in thought mode.

Mystery Man

Oddly enough, it was How to Train Your Dragon that fired this one off. Yeah, I know. I'm odd.

user-pic

best moive ever

user-pic

Can I say that I'm not ashamed to admit that I want to grow up to be Miranda Priestly? Well Meryl Streep as Miranda Priestly, maybe not the fashion part, but that strength, integrity, power, and elegance is everything I've ever wanted to be.

Sherri

YAY FOR FIREFLY! :D i get so happy whenever it's referenced. i love all those women, i find them all to be great role models. (my female role model growing up was Captain Janeway from Star Trek Voyager :D)

Mystery Man

Janeway, to me, is the exception that tests the rule. The film and TV industry CAN do brilliant female characters. They just seem not to want to.

silkysly

I was intrigued by the cast of characters you described, but sorry to say…, I never saw the show. :-/

Tariana

I was sighing all the way through the list. Damn, MM. You ought to be writing books with lines like this: "He may be a leaf on the wind, she is his wind. That is something worth having." Very dreamy.

user-pic

I just finished watching the series and it feels kind of awesome to be in the know. They are all awesome women one could aspire to be; except maybe a professional prostitute despite the fact that she is my favorite. Did you see heart of gold? Totally relatable.

Kate

My fiance introduced me to Firefly, among many other things. It's nice to share such similar tastes, we can go from watching Beauty and the Beast to The Sopranos, haha.

user-pic

I have put a voodoo curse on whichever executive at FOX screwed that amazing show over. They could have rivaled battlestar galatica in their awesomeness. BUT WE WILL NEVER FUCKING KNOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Tariana

I have a question too, MM.

When a man says to a woman, "You are one dangerous woman" or something to that effect (you know MJ's song "Dangerous"?), what exactly does that mean?

Mystery Man

Can be two things. Psycho or total respect/fear.

Tariana

Total respect/fear??? Fear of what???

Mystery Man

Let me think on that. I know what I mean, just not quite how to say it.

Tariana

=D

Toy Honey Lung

Well, this is awkward for sure.
Where did this sudden pang of hatred come from?

All that aside, tell me:

What amazing and great deeds would someone have to accomplish to deserve such an amazing, albeit imaginary, superwoman.

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive: