Guyspeak Newsletter Signup

Relationships

Next Entry »
userpic

Survey Of Douchebags Reveals Half of Men Would Dump Their Girlfriends For Getting Fat

That bastion of journalistic integrity AskMen.com has published their latest "Great Male" survey, a look at what douchebags men think about pressing dating issues like sexting and whether or not angels exist. As Gawker points out, one of the more disturbing findings is that half of all straight men surveyed claim they would dump a girlfriend for getting fat. (Meanwhile, 20% of straight women would keelhaul their newly hefty boyfriend.)

On the plus side, 53% of men said that weight gain wouldn't be grounds for dumping. So at least you have a 50/50-ish chance of finding a nice guy among the many, many jerks.

I have a few questions here:

-- Did Ask Men conduct this survey in a bar filled with doucherockets who reeked of Axe body spray and vodka Red Bulls?

-- How many of the guys surveyed actually have girlfriends? Is it a hypothetical situation ("If I move out of my parent's basement and get a girlfriend, she better not get fat!") or are these guys who are currently in relationships? If it's the latter, I feel sorry for their girlfriends.

-- Half of the men out there would really just cut and run? They're really that concerned with looks? Personality, sense of humor, love...none of that stuff matters? If she wanted to get in shape, they wouldn't support their lady? They'd just bail? Man, that is depressing.

-- To the 53% who said they would dump their girlfriend for gaining weight: Seriously? You're that superficial? Well, I sure hope you're a male model. What's that? You're just some trollish, judgmental dude? Good luck with that.

-- According to the survey, 51% of men would be offended if they discovered their lady was faking her orgasms. My guess is that's also the percentage who would dump their girlfriend for gaining weight. Chances are they have no idea how to please a woman.

-- No, seriously, did they just take a poll of douchebags? Who conducted this survey, The Situation from Jersey Shore?

And my question to you guys: Would you dump a guy for gaining weight? And would you continue to date a guy who said he would break up with you if you became overweight?

You can read more of the survey's findings, including questions about snooping and how many dates a guy should pay for, here. Don't say I didn't warn you.

Talk 30
Love it? Hate it? 6
Got A Question? Ask Your Own. »

30 Comments

user-pic

Question #6...
Of the choices listed below, which one thing would you change about your partner?
46% are single.

Bibonoshoes

question 20 : "How often does your partner make an effort to be romantic ?
35 % are single. Are they the same guys than at the beginning of the survey or did the 11% difference find someone between question 6 and question 20 ?

It definitely shows that these studies are not reliable material...

user-pic

Oh this must be a survey of the segment of the male population who expect to date hot thin ladies who won't "just eat a salad" on a date, exhibiting a blatant lack of understanding as to how WEIGHT GAIN works.

You want a thin girl? Then don't bitch to your friends about how she only ate a salad on a date. Salad is cheaper than steak. She just did you a favor. Sheesh.

I feel obligated to stay a maximum of 110 lbs while my boyfriend continues to get fat. But you know what? I'd still hit it even if he was 250. I'd just be sure I didn't get crushed.

user-pic

Weight gain can occur if you are fat or thin!!!!! I don't think it referred to men with expectations of dating 'thin' girls. I am sure everyone is different but to be honest, if my partner started to gain weight (and i don't mean the extra pounds you gain over winter) but seriously gain weight and started to show no interest in taking care of his health - I would be turned off. I like people who take a healthy interest in their lives and who take care of themselves to some degree. Whatever they look like - just knowing that he cares enough about himself to look after himself physically is attractive (for me!). If my partner started to get sloppy and had that mentality of "well I got the girl now I can just relax and let my personality do all the work" - it wouldn't cut it. If I keep myself looking good for him - i have the same expectations from him. Sure I love him, his personality, his sense of humour but without a healthy lifestyle and some degree of interest in how he looks... I don't know ..... I wouldn't necessarily leave him BUT I would be on his case making sure he takes care of himself, I would support and encourage a healthy lifestyle - and if he didn't even bother after that - then I guess I would slowly lose interest. Having a great personality means ALOT to me in a partner but I can't have a relationship based solely on personality. I don't expect perfection, or a great body or movie star looks but physical attractiveness plays an important factor too.

user-pic

Weight gain isn't a reason to drop someone; my boyfriend's a little bit on the teddy-bearish side while I'm lean and work out six days a week, but you know what? He treats me like I'm the most beautiful girl in the world (:

and if he were to really want to lose weight, I'd show him the ropes and we'd do it together.

user-pic

Funny thing about weight for me - a silly 10lbs that come and goes, likes to come at the holidays and goes away before the next holiday. Here's my Friend, family and dating feed back

Family, down 10lbs - just right - up 10lbs - just right (they just love me)
Friends, down 10lbs : getting too thin - up 10lbs : about right
Dates, down 10lbs : some weight to loose - up 10lbs : a bit over weight (feed back from friends on recent 3 blind dates)

Actual Size: 5'4" and 132lbs (I am happy with my 10 up or down but found it funny how others see it) 3 blind dates - just that, dates that ended never to be dated again. And funny, none were in shape themselves.

Funny Survey and great overview of it! Thanks for sharing with us - as for me, nope would not drop someone for weight gain. Its life and really I would be with them because there was something more to them then their weight.

user-pic

No fat bitches, please.

user-pic

My BF has said a few times that he'd dump me if I get fat. He's only half serious (he's got a really wierd sense of humor...). My response? "I don't stay fit for YOU. I do it for ME."

user-pic

No fat assholes, either, Mark. Just sayin'...

goodkarmagirl

WooooHooooo Nick. You sure got em all fired up with this one.

Awesome , awesome post. Best wit and sass I've seen of late. Also, I'd give ya the winner of the "Best Use of the term Douchebags" for the week. BRAVO.

nikitamaagel

What do you have against Axe? I think it smells amazing on a guy (okay, maybe a little highschoolish, but who cares!)

Nick Nadel

Real men use Old Spice.

nikitamaagel

That smells amazing too. I guess I'm not picky.

VX

There are several things to take issue with. One is everyone is entitled to their opinion. Yes fat is very unhealthy. And that sounds about right for the dating group What has been over looked is how people treat the other (gender neutral). A person that is no longer attractive to one are they going to be treated in the same way as before? How about a woman saying he has to be taller than in when I wear high heels. is that what shallow?
And it said: "Half of Men Would Dump Their Girlfriends For Getting Fat"
Now let's face it FAT does not mean 10-15 lbs it means quite a bit more and not muscle (muscle masses more than fat so a person could drop clothes sizes yet weigh more).

Nick Nadel

Sure, everyone is entitled to their opinion and what constitutes overweight varies from person to person. It just surprised me that over half the men surveyed would dump their girlfriend for gaining weight. Everything else could be perfect, but gain weight and there outie-5000. I wonder how many guys would dump their girlfriends for getting dangerously thin. People have such a problem with those who they deem overweight or "fat" these days...

user-pic

No it's just you, because you're fat you feel offended. There is nothing wrong with wanting to dump your girlfriend if you no longer feel attracted to her, but it seems you are too busy bashing down other guys (douchebags, axe, so on) for doing what you consider to be a mayor fault. Most likely you were dumped or just never got a girlfriend ever and that's why you're so butt hurt about it.

user-pic

If my guy started to gain a little weight, there's no way I would leave him in the dust. But, if was to the point where he was severely compromising his health I would be worried and talk to him. If he made a conscious decision to keep gaining weight then I might break it off. I just wouldn't be able to watch him slowly kill himself.

user-pic

That is disturbing...what about if they get their girlfriends pregnant? Are all those men going to dump their girlfriends too for gaining all that baby weight?!

I wouldn't dump a guy for gaining weight but I would suggest working out together if it really became an issue. Besides its much more fun when you do it together! :) In fact, my last bf, when he started to lose weight, I freaked out a bit because I was so used to him being much bigger and I tried to get him to stay the same weight instead of losing it! Haha!

user-pic

This says they would dump a gf for getting "fat," not "gaining weight." While I am sure some of those respondents were douches, I can't disagree with the reason the non-douches probably chose this response. I think its a matter of context. If my bf got fat because he had a thyroid problem, that wouldn't be an issue to me. The same goes with those pounds that come with age. But if, while young and agile, he decided to quit taking care of himself and just got grossly fat from poor eating, copious drinking, and a sedentary lifestyle? Then yea, I would consider dumping him, because it is a matter of taking pride in oneself and making a reasonable effort to be healthy. Additionally, if he is losing interest in his health in his 20s or 30s, I can't imagine that he is going to be a healthy 50 or 60 year old. That's just grounds for an early diagnosis of high BP, diabetes, hypertension, back problems, knee problems, etc., all due to a lack of concern for one's own health.

user-pic

Yeah, reading that survey made me feel terribly inadequate and not very hopeful about finding a bf eventually. :(

Miss Somnus

I would never let my man slip away just cause he gain couple pounds,as i still adore him! It is normal to gain weight, but it should have a balance, if he keep gaining weight without taking care of himself, i would talk to him.
Not because i want to persuade him to lose weight,but a person's attitude toward something won't change so suddenlly, it gotta have some unspoken issues in his heart. And i need to do is to make the 1st movie, find it out and guide him back on the healthy path.
Instead of physical attract, the personality, whether we can understand each other or engage in a conversation seem way more important to me.
I would never date a dude if he dump me for weight problem, as a matter of fact, i never will give that douch a chance to make their further move. The way they look already reveal their intensions. Having conversations with my body won't take them any further. Those guys are simply waste of oxygen, i won't allow my heart break for them! Not even a second!

user-pic

well i can sort of see where these guys are coming from. i would never dump a boyfriend if he gained 5 pounds or something miniscule(my boyfriend has gained and lost 20 over the course of our relationship and i have not noticed....). but really if someone I dated got up to like 300 pounds without any concern for their health...I would probably dump them. I mean its not just about my ego, but really do you want to be with someone who doesn't care about their health? who can't go for a walk with you? who wouldn't be able to play outside with your kids because of his size?

user-pic

I call shenanigans~! So, according to them, fifty three percent of men from seemingly all walks of life would dump their significant other if she happened to gain some extra rolls. Fifty three percent. Really? I want to know what their definition of FAT is. I've seen men compare women who I've only considered a tad chubby to freaking manatees.

Perhaps they should be more specific next time and add a BMI chart.

Meh.

This survey perplexes me but it doesn't make me feel insecure about myself or make me want to hold myself to higher standards. Screw that s***t, it's hard enough being a woman as is.

user-pic

I am overweight myself, but I have been with my boyfriend for almost 3 years. He was a normal, average weight when we started dating, although he never worked out. When we first met, I was 20 pounds heavier than I am now, but about the same weight as when we started dating. My weight has not significantly changed.

Meanwhile, my boyfriend put on 15 - 20 pounds. He has a beer belly. And you know what? I loved him when he was 'thin.' And I love him now that he's chubby. I am still just as physically attracted. And I probably would still feel that way even another 15 or 20 down the road. My only concern is that, as someone who has seen the life of a 'fat person,' I don't want him to deal with the same cruelty from society. I want him to be happy and healthy. But even if he gains more weight, I would stay.

Sure, his looks attracted me to him. But I am far more invested than just how he looks now.

user-pic

I actaully have a friend who's considering dumping her bf because he's gaining weight, so this goes both ways. Of course, I also know a guy who began dating a girl after she lost a lot of weight, even though he *claims* he liked her before she did. Funny how he didn't ask her out then though. :/

user-pic

So he eats his heart out when you lose the weight and are happy with someone else...

user-pic

I have to say that for the past couple of hours i have been hooked by the amazing articles on this website. Keep up the good work.

user-pic

I've dated two girls who were slightly overweight. The first ate junk food constantly and refused to work out at all, even though I was always offering to take her with me on my workouts. That girl got dumped. The current girlfriend has some muffin top but she eats pretty healthy meals and she's willing to work out with me. She's a keeper.

Fat isn't necessarily unattractive. Refusing to take care of yourself is.

user-pic

That was pretty helpful thing! But i have few questions. Can u give me contact info?

Leave a comment

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Get GuySpeak in your inbox.

Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive:

Trending Topics

  1. 123 entries are tagged with
  2. 82 entries are tagged with
  3. 111 entries are tagged with
  4. 78 entries are tagged with
  5. 111 entries are tagged with
  6. 316 entries are tagged with
  7. 118 entries are tagged with
  8. 1139 entries are tagged with
  9. 84 entries are tagged with
  10. 93 entries are tagged with
  11. 79 entries are tagged with
  12. 121 entries are tagged with
  13. 125 entries are tagged with
  14. 92 entries are tagged with
  15. 97 entries are tagged with
  16. 94 entries are tagged with
  17. 199 entries are tagged with
  18. 237 entries are tagged with
  19. 80 entries are tagged with
  20. 79 entries are tagged with
  21. 84 entries are tagged with
  22. 273 entries are tagged with
  23. 767 entries are tagged with
  24. 95 entries are tagged with
  25. 88 entries are tagged with